Westcliff All Americans
| YEAR | SPORT | ||
| 2025-2026 | |||
| Jordyn Gather | Women's Soccer | NAIA 3rd Team All American | |
| 2024-2025 | |||
| Jysabella Tolentino | Women's Soccer | NAIA 3rd Team All American | |
| Rodolfo Beigelmeyer | Men's Volleyball | AVCA All American Honorable Mention | |
| Benjamin Riscanevo | Cheer | NCA All American | |
| Barbara Lamonier | Cheer | NCA All American | |
| Juan Alejandro Diaz | Cheer | NCA All American | |
| Marie Felise Pascua | Cheer | NCA All American | |
| Rheanna Shah | Cheer | NCA All American | |
| Yamille Casillas | Cheer | NCA All American | |
| Sam Chew | Cheer | NCA All American | |
| 2023-2024 | |||
| John Adekunle | Men's Soccer | NAIA 3rd Team All American | |
| Gabriel Pizza | Men's Volleyball | AVCA All American Honorable Mention | |
| Max Mueller | Men's Tennis | NAIA 3rd Team All American | |
| Felix Veyhle | Men's Tennis | NAIA 3rd Team All American | |
| Anna Ruiz Masip | Women's Tennis | NAIA 2nd Team All American | |
| Elena Gunfaus | Women's Tennis | NAIA 3rd Team All American | |
| Leonel Franco Garcia Mesas | Cheer | NCA All American | |
| Madison Emily Balsz | Cheer | NCA All American | |
| Paz Yamile Gutierrez Casillas | Cheer | NCA All American | |
| 2022-2023 | |||
| Christine Thorvaldsen | Women's Soccer | NAIA All American Honorable Mention | |
| Fiona Moesching | Women's Volleyball | NAIA All American Honorable Mention | |
| Marielena Muench | Women's Tennis | NAIA 2nd Team All American | |
| Zak Khalil | Men's Tennis | NAIA 2nd Team All American | |
| Nicolas Pulido | Cheer | NCA All American | |
| Alejandro Diaz | Cheer | NCA All American | |
| Rheanna Shaw | Cheer | NCA All American | |
| Christian Manzo | Cheer | NCA All American | |
| Uly Duran | Baseball | NAIA All American Honorable Mention | |
| 2021-2022 | |||
| Quentin Hornung | Men's Soccer | NAIA All American Honorable Mention | |
| Shayee Sherif | Women's Tennis | NAIA All American Honorable Mention | |
| Trinity Vasquez | Women's Basketball | NAIA All American Honorable Mention | |
| Avery Chadwick | Cheer | NCA All American | |
| Nicolas Pulido | Cheer | NCA All American |